Decision Paralysis: The Jam Study Was Smaller Than the Story
The Compass Team
November 20, 2026
On a Saturday in 1995, a table of jams went up in a gourmet grocery store in Menlo Park, California. Some days it held six jars. Other days, 24. The study became the standard reference for decision paralysis, and the version everyone repeats is cleaner than the result. Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper sat behind it with a stack of one-dollar coupons and counted what happened next.
More people stopped at the bigger table, 60 percent of passers-by against 40 percent. Then came the result that made the study famous. 30 percent of the people who tasted from the six-jar table bought a jar. 3 percent at the 24-jar table did.
Iyengar's own summary to the New York Times in 2010 was careful. The study "raised the hypothesis that the presence of choice might be appealing as a theory," she said, while in reality people might find more and more choice "to actually be debilitating."
Copies of the experiment ran on chocolate and on speed dating. The paradox of choice became a book, a talk, and a shelf of airport management advice.
Thirty years of follow-up have made the picture smaller and more useful.
A 2024 review of the choice overload literature (Misuraca and colleagues, Frontiers in Psychology) sorts the moderators into two piles: things about the choice environment, and things about the person choosing. The effect is real. Whether it is general is a different question.
The environment side is comparability. The reviewers organise this around decision task difficulty and choice set complexity. Six flavours differ on one axis, so they are easy to compare. Twenty options that differ on four attributes each are not, and the same 20 that differ on one axis are easy again.
There is no number of options where overload switches on, and any page that hands you one is inventing it.
The person side is preference uncertainty. A 2022 survey study (Adriatico and colleagues, Journal of Economics, Finance and Accounting Studies) tested five candidate causes against decision paralysis in consumers: decision task difficulty, choice set complexity, preference uncertainty, decision goal, and asymmetric information. The two that did the work were decision task difficulty and asymmetric information, meaning options you cannot compare, and a chooser holding less information than the options require.
An open decision-science text lists what paralysis needs in order to happen at all: no strong prior bias towards one option, options of roughly equal quality, and unfamiliarity with the choice. Take any one of those away and people decide. Someone who already knows what they want, facing one clearly better option, in a category they have bought before, does not freeze.
Now put a founder at that table. Twenty-four live decisions, each with four attributes, none of them comparable with the others, and no prior bias because the founder is the one who has to invent the criteria. That configuration is the one the research says produces deferral, and it has nothing to do with willpower.
The useful part of the jam study sits in the small table. Those shoppers were choosing between things they could tell apart.
Which gives a founder something to do that is more specific than being more decisive. Before the options multiply, write the three or four criteria that would make each option wrong.
One line each, in the week the decision shows up. The choice set stops being 24 incomparable things and becomes a comparison against your own written criteria, which is a task you can finish in an hour.
It also makes the second decision faster. Six months later the same question resurfaces with the same criteria attached, and you can see whether you already ruled it out, and on what grounds.
Founders rarely have too many options. They have too few criteria.
Share this article